Mt. Rainier and Lenticular Clouds - Dec. 2008 copyright: JMM
Showing posts with label Harper Lee. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Harper Lee. Show all posts

July 25, 2015

Go Set a Watchman


SPOILER ALERT.......SPOILER ALERT.....SPOILER ALERT

If you haven't read the book yet, don't read this review or my thoughts on it!!!!

Well after much fanfare and waiting, Harper Lee's long lost manuscript was published and distributed on July 14th.  There has been some controversy surrounding it because Harper Lee may or may not have given her blessing to publish it.  It's somewhat suspect that the manuscript surfaced after Ms. Lee's sister Alice passed away.  Alice was a lawyer, like their father, and tended to all of Ms. Lee's affairs, contracts and royalties from To Kill a Mockingbird.  Ms. Lee is about 88 and it's unclear if she is having memory problems.  

The manuscript was written in the 1950s, was apparently shopped around with no takers.  Then a few years later, TKAM was published and let's face it, that's a hard act to follow.  Your first novel wins the Pulitzer Price and everyone wants a piece of you, to discuss it over and over to the point where Ms. Lee refused to discuss 'the book', as she referred to it.  Then an incredible movie adaptation is made and again, another hard act to follow.  Has anyone noticed that it's probably one of the few old movies that has never been remade?  You just can't mess with perfection.  But I digress.

Go Set a Watchman takes place about 20-25 years after TKAM.  Same characters....Scout, Atticus, Uncle Jack, Aunt Alexandra.  Scout....or Jean Louise as she's known now that she's in her 20s....lives in New York City but goes to visit her family in Maycomb, Alabama.  Civil rights is in it's infancy, the NAACP is making it's presence known, race relations are very tense.  Jean Louise lives in the north and doesn't even notice people of other races anymore because she's surrounded by them.  You get colourblind in a big city like NYC.  Washington DC has made some new laws which affect the south and they don't like it one bit down there.  

Jean Louise takes up with her longtime friend and now suitor, Henry, or 'Hank', who is Atticus' protege and law partner.  Her brother Jem passed away from a heart attack...that tidbit of info was pretty devastating to learn.  But Jean Louise notices that things are different....very different...in her old hometown.  She goes to visit their former housekeeper, Calpurnia, and her visit draws stares from the other black people.  Cal won't look at her or talk to her, which of course upsets and confuses her. 

Cal's grandson has just been arrested for running over and killing a white man in town, and Atticus has taken the case, just like he took Tom Robinson's rape case when Jean Louise was a child, which as we know is one of the themes of TKAM.  A side note:  The facts of that case are a little bit different in GSAW, and I don't understand why that wasn't edited to match TKAM.  

Unfortunately, Jean Louise discovers a very racist brochure on her father's desk, which leads her downtown to sneak into a meeting of all of the men in Maycomb, including Atticus and Hank, where they are discussing 'the negro problem' and NAACP's meddling.  Horrified, she leaves the meeting, absolutely reeling from the realization that her sainted, beloved, fair father is as racist as the other men in town.  She was considering marrying Hank, possibly moving home to Maycomb, but now she can't stand the thought.  

At this point she goes to visit her Uncle Jack and this is where the book bogged down for me.  The dialog between the two of them was really tedious.  I found myself spacing out.  When she confronts Atticus and they argue, again I found it tedious.  He forced her to admit that she had many of the same opinions as the southerners because she IS a southerner.  

The book ends with no resolution to anything, in my opinion.  I thought it was a pretty dry read overall.  Certainly didn't measure up to TKAM, which is just a masterpiece.  The best parts where when Jean Louise was reminiscing about her childhood and teen years.  I was disappointed considering the build up and excitement I had to read this.  I can see why Ms. Lee couldn't find a publisher for it at the time because it would have been considered somewhat incendiary for the time. TKAM was published in 1961 but takes place in the 1930s.  GSAW was written in the mid 50s and takes place in the mid 50s, by an Alabaman woman living in NYC, just like Jean Louise.  

Finally, the title of the book continues to evade my understanding.  It's apparently a bible quote, "For thus the Lord said to me:  Go, set a watchman, let him announce what he sees." Maybe if the comma was returned between 'Go' and 'Set' it would make more sense?  Is Jean Louise the watchman announcing what she sees in Maycomb?  I don't get it.  At least with TKAM, it was clear.  Both Boo Radley and Tom Robinson were the mockingbirds, and it was a sin to kill a mockingbird.  

It's worth a read if you are a fan of TKAM.  Maybe other people will find it an excellent read....based on the comments on the book's Facebook page, I'm clearly in the minority....sadly, I did not. 

February 24, 2010

Quite Possibly the Best Book and Movie EVER

IMHO, anyway. (spoiler alert: plot giveaways ahead)
TKAM, or 'Mockingbird' as I prefer to call it, was required reading for my 10th grade high school English class. I fell into it completely and totally, the instant I started it. I remember we had just started it in class during the week, and over the weekend I could not put it down, reading it ever spare second I could. That Sunday afternoon, my homework was done, I was already about halfway through the book and I didn't want to get too far ahead, so I decided to see what was on TV. I turned on Channel 38 just as Mockingbird-the-movie was about to start!!! I knew Mrs. Pearson would kill me if I watched it, but I didn't care. I was already chapters ahead of the class anyway. So I settled into the beanbag chair in my room, and got ready for an incredible ride. A couple of hours later, and crying my eyes out, I grabbed the book off of my desk and killed it by bedtime. The next day when I got to English, I told Mrs. Pearson that Mockingbird had been on TV the day before, and that I watched it. She was distressed, "What?! You weren't supposed to watch it!" I waved her off and said, "Don't worry, I finished the book last night too." She just laughed and told me not to tell anyone in the class how it ends. Needless to say, I found myself participating in class discussions more than was normal for me, and bursting with impatience for my classmates to hurry up and finish so that we could talk about the end!!


For those of you who have never read the book or seen the movie, it's set in Depression-era Alabama, in the fictional town and county of Maycomb. Maycomb is based upon author Harper Lee's hometown of Monroeville, Alabama. The story is told from the perspective of Jean Louise Finch, "Scout", who is remembering the events that took place over the course of a couple of summers when she was a child in the 30's. The book, of course, is much longer and more detailed than the movie, which had to condense, and eliminate, many of the different elements of the book. Scout lives with her older brother Jeremy, "Jem", and their father, Atticus, who is a lawyer. Their mom died when Scout was 2, and Atticus employs a black woman, Calpurnia, to help with the kids and around the house, and Cal is very much a mother figure to the kids. Atticus raises his well-mannered children in a home free of prejudice and/or hate, despite it being the deep South in those times. In fact, several of the townspeople are portrayed as being far more open minded than one would think, including the Judge, Sheriff and neighbor Miss Maudie.

Scout sets the scene, both in the book & movie, as follows:

"Maycomb was a tired old town, even in 1932 when I first knew it. Somehow it was hotter then. Men's stiff collars wilted by nine in the morning. Ladies bathed before noon, after their three o'clock naps, and by nightfall were like soft teacakes with frosting from sweating and sweet talcum. The day was twenty-four hours long, but it seemed longer. There's no hurry, for there's nowhere to go and nothing to buy... and no money to buy it with. Although Maycomb County had recently been told that it had nothing to fear but fear itself... that summer, I was six years old."

There are 2 themes in the book. The first is of the children's world, their friend Dill Harris & their very overactive imaginations, and the mysterious neighbor, Boo Radley, who never leaves his home, and with whom the children are obsessed. The second theme is much darker. Atticus is appointed to defend Tom Robinson, a black man, who is being accused of having raped Mayella Ewell. The Ewells are a repugnant bunch; the lowest of the low class of white people in those times. Still, they are white, and no white jury is going to find a black man innocent, even though it is 100% clear that Tom is not guilty. Most Court appointed attorneys would provide the most basic of defenses for a black client. However, Atticus makes no secret of the fact that he will defend Tom to the fullest, which enrages Mayella's father, Bob Ewell. The children also have to put up with a lot of crap from classmates and townspeople because of Atticus' decision to take Tom's case, often being called "n***** lover". A good portion of the movie/book deals with Tom's trial, and the explosive aftermath. Both themes dovetail beautifully at the end, as Scout astutely discovers what, rather who, the Mockingbird represents.

I can honestly say that the movie is as good as the book. And the reason is that Harper Lee was on the set, and approved of the screenplay, script changes and casting. Gregory Peck reminded her so much of her father, Amasa Lee, (on whom Atticus is based) that she gave Peck her father's pocket watch. The character Dill Harris is based on Lee's childhood friend, Truman Capote. Boo was based on a reclusive neighbor of Lee's as well. And by the way, Gregory Peck was absolutely born to play this role. Peck himself stayed up all night reading the script and couldn't wait to start filming, and has said it was the highlight of his long career. He got an Oscar for it. This movie is perfectly cast. I was reading the Mockingbird trivia on IMDB and I cannot imagine what it would have been like if Rock Hudson or Jimmy Stewart had played Atticus. The children are so engaging and they played a lot of make-believe and other games, like I played with my cousins, so from that standpoint, it reminded me of my own childhood growing up in a small, rural town.

Mary Badham, who plays Scout, was nominated for an Academy Award. She was so magical in the scenes with Peck. And the scene when she, Jem & Dill go to 'rescue' Atticus from the angry mob that show up at the jailhouse to take out their own brand of justice on Tom, is riveting. Scout doesn't quite understand what is going on, other than fact that her father is being threatened by these people, because he is defending Tom Robinson. She looks over the crowd and finds a familiar face: The father of a classmate who had lunch at the Finch home one school day the year before. She calls out, "Hey Mr. Cunningham! Remember me? I'm Jean Louise Finch. You brought us some hickory nuts one early morning. I got my daddy to come out and thank you." The angry mob of men shift uncomfortably as Scout continues, "I go to school with your boy! I go to school with Walter! He's a nice boy, tell him 'hey' for me!' Scout continues talking until she realizes that she's been talking too much. Embarrassed, she hangs her head and says, 'I sure meant no harm Mr. Cunningham'. By this point, the men are completely shamed. Mr. Cunningham finally speaks up, 'No harm taken, young lady. I'll tell Walter you said Hey." It's absolutely brilliant the way a child snapped those men out of their intent to remove Atticus by force and lynch Tom Robinson.

I found the movie poster at the antique show in Puyallup a few years ago. When I was at Universal Studios in LA in 1986, the tour tram went right by the Finch house. It was so fast that I couldn't get a photo of it, but at least I can say I saw the house! Of all the old movies that have been remade, I am so pleased that no one has dared to improve on this classic. The cinematography is top notch. The black & white adds even more of a nostaglic flavour to it, not to mention a good amount of creepiness in all the right places. I truly do not believe that I would love Mockingbird as much as I do had it been in colour.

One of the reasons I love Atticus Finch in the book, and especially as portrayed by Gregory Peck, is that he reminds me so much of my own dad. My father was a very fair, gentle-but-firm, and well-respected man in my hometown. He was level headed and always tried to do the right thing, even if it wasn't popular to do so. He possessed so many of the same qualities as Atticus. Even looked like him a bit.


Can you see the resemblance? Because I sure do. This is my dad right before the July 4th parade in 1975.

When my dad died in 2003, I was racing around the house trying to pack to get back east as soon as I could, and I needed to have a book with me. I grabbed Mockingbird out of habit, but it only occurred to me a few years later what I had done on a subconscious level. At the time I wasn't actually consciously thinking about Atticus and dad at all. I just needed a book that I loved and one that was an easy read, and Mockingbird has always been my 'go-to' book. But I definitely wasn't thinking, 'hey, I know, let's compound my grief by reading a book about my dad....'

Back in the mid-90's, I had taken some time off at the end of October...I think it was 1996...so I was home on Halloween which fell on a weekday. We never got trick or treaters, so I knew I could kick back with a movie undisturbed, so I of course chose Mockingbird. Thus began a long standing tradition of watching it on Halloween. The final scene of the movie actually takes place on Halloween night and it's pretty creepy.

Of course I hunted down the soundtrack as well. The movie score, composed by Elmer Bernstein, is absolutely amazing. Bernstein manages to perfectly capture the wonder of a child's world with his delicate piano, played to sound like a music box, which then swells into the main "Mockingbird Theme", both beautiful and nostalgic, yet poignant and heartbreaking at the same time. I love it so much, and it moves me to tears every time I hear it, and since I have it on a few cassette tapes that I listen to regularly, I hear it a lot. Still chokes me up.

The score captivates from the second the movie starts all the way through to the end credits, which when accompanied by the visual of young Scout walking Boo Radley home with the adult Scout's narration, brings me to instant weeping. I have seen this movie hundreds and hundreds of times, and I cry every. single. time.

"Neighbors bring food with death... and flowers with sickness... and little things in between. Boo was our neighbor. He gave us two soap dolls, a broken watch and chain, a knife... and our lives. One time Atticus said... you never really knew a man until you stood in his shoes and walked around in them. Just standing on the Radley porch was enough. The summer that had begun so long ago had ended, and another summer had taken its place. And a fall. And Boo Radley had come out. I was to think of these days many times, of Jem and Dill... and Boo Radley and Tom Robinson. And Atticus. He would be in Jem's room all night, and he would be there when Jem waked up in the morning."

See it or read it. I guarantee you won't be sorry.